Progressive vs Geico: Real Rates From Our Own Quotes

Forget advertised teaser rates โ€” here is what each carrier actually quoted our shoppers, state by state. Licensed agents at A Plus Insurance log every quote we run โ€” since late 2025, updated automatically as new quotes come in:

Progressive: Average Rate by State

Based on 1149 real quotes A Plus Insurance ran, the typical rate in this view is about $219/mo (median $153), ranging $12 to $5185.

MO
$65/mo (n=7)
OK
$86/mo (n=8)
OH
$99/mo (n=5)
AZ
$106/mo (n=21)
NC
$155/mo (n=47)
FL
$177/mo (n=18)
TX
$186/mo (n=12)
GA
$188/mo (n=11)
CO
$224/mo (n=844)
OR
$228/mo (n=12)
SC
$242/mo (n=111)
AK
$305/mo (n=23)

Source: A Plus Insurance first-party quote data.

Geico: Average Rate by State

Based on 310 real quotes A Plus Insurance ran, the typical rate in this view is about $203/mo (median $175), ranging $24 to $1639.

OK
$88/mo (n=4)
FL
$187/mo (n=4)
GA
$198/mo (n=4)
TX
$202/mo (n=9)
SC
$203/mo (n=67)
CO
$203/mo (n=198)
AK
$215/mo (n=10)
OR
$293/mo (n=7)
Show the 330 quotes behind this chart
DateStCityZIPAgeSexMaritalYrMakeModelCoverageCarrier$/moViolAccSR22
2026-07-27AKWillow9968845femaleMarried1990GMCVanduraliability_onlyGeico$2400-
2026-09-03COGrand Junction8150144maleSingle2013ChevroletImpalaliability_onlyGeico$2600Y
2026-09-07CODenver8021133maleSingle2018VolvoXC60 T5liability_onlyGeico$2600-
2026-08-22AKDutch Harbor9969241femaleSingle1999Toyota4Runnerliability_onlyGeico$3400-
2026-08-28COColorado Springs8090447femaleSingle1998SubaruLegacyliability_onlyGeico$3600-
2026-06-24COHartsel8044967femaleSingle2006ChevroletTrailblazerliability_onlyGeico$4000-
2026-09-09COColorado Springs8091060femaleWidowed2004HyundaiSonataliability_onlyGeico$4200-
2026-08-30COGreeley8063160femaleSingle2003FordWindstarliability_onlyGeico$4200-
2026-09-09COColorado Springs8091060femaleWidowed2004HyundaiSonataliability_onlyGeico$4400-
2026-09-01COCASCADE8080944maleSingle2022ToyotaRAV4liability_onlyGeico$4400-
2026-08-26COColorado Springs8090966maleSingle2011CadillacCTSliability_onlyGeico$4500-
2026-09-08COAurora8001129maleSingle2000GMCSierraliability_onlyGeico$4502-
2026-07-09COArvada8000235femaleSingle2016KiaSoulliability_onlyGeico$4600-
2026-03-30COPueblo8100149maleSingle1997FordF-150liability_onlyGeico$4600-
2026-08-10CORockvale81244------liability_onlyGeico$4700-
2026-09-05COGRAND JUNCTION81501-femaleSingle---liability_onlyGeico$4900-
2026-08-28COClifton8152034maleMarried2005FordExplorerliability_onlyGeico$5000-
2026-08-15COBoulder8030468maleSingle1996JeepGrand Cherokeeliability_onlyGeico$5100-
2026-05-11OK---unknownunknown1999Land Rover-liability_onlyGeico$52---
2026-04-20COFort Collins8052470femaleSingle2012VolvoXC60liability_onlyGeico$5200-
2026-06-26SCAnderson2962562maleMarried2015HyundaiGenesisliability_onlyGeico$5300-
2026-06-26SCAnderson2962562maleMarried2015HyundaiGenesisliability_onlyGeico$5300-
2026-06-26SCAnderson2962562maleMarried2015HyundaiGenesisliability_onlyGeico$5300-
2026-09-02COGrand Junction81501-499128femaleSingle2014ChevroletCaptiva Sportliability_onlyGeico$5400-
2026-04-08IAMay City50401-unknownunknown2007CadillacEscaladeliability_onlyGeico$5400Y
2026-09-01SCYork2974546femaleSingle2014ToyotaHighlanderliability_onlyGeico$5500-
2026-09-04CODenver8026031femaleSingle2017HyundaiSanta Fe Sportliability_onlyGeico$5600-
2026-08-05SCRock Hill2973230femaleMarried2011KiaOptimaliability_onlyGeico$5800-
2026-08-25COColorado Springs8091955maleSingle2009NissanMuranoliability_onlyGeico$5800-
2026-06-24CONORTHGLENN8023463femaleSingle2005DodgeDurangoliability_onlyGeico$6000-
2026-09-04CODenver8026031femaleSingle2017HyundaiSanta Fe Sportliability_onlyGeico$6000-
2026-07-21SCLiberty2965774maleSingle2018RAM1500liability_onlyGeico$6200-
2026-08-17CODenver8026032maleSingle2017NissanMaximaliability_onlyGeico$6211-
2026-08-05CO-80231-maleSingle2018ToyotaCamryliability_onlyGeico$6200-
2026-09-02SCSimpsonville2968176maleSingle2014HyundaiEquusfull_coverageGeico$6500-
2026-03-31COFountain-26unknownSingle1985ChevroletCapriceliability_onlyGeico$6621-
2026-08-24COPueblo8100856femaleMarried2012ToyotaScion iQliability_onlyGeico$6600-
2026-09-07COThornton8023348maleSingle2016MazdaCX-5liability_onlyGeico$6800-
2026-08-26COColorado Springs8090532maleSingle2000FordFocusliability_onlyGeico$7100-
2026-06-24COManitou Springs80829------liability_onlyGeico$7200-
2026-05-29SCHickin2967178unknownunknown2000-Camryliability_onlyGeico$741--
2026-09-01COColorado Springs8092121femaleSingle2000MazdaProtegeliability_onlyGeico$7400-
2026-09-03COColorado Springs8091028femaleSingle2008HondaAccordliability_onlyGeico$7400-
2026-06-24COEnglewood8011033maleSingle2014DodgeChargerliability_onlyGeico$7600-
2026-08-24AKHomer9960333maleMarried2013FordFiestaliability_onlyGeico$7700-
2026-07-27COLamar8105244maleSingle2004ToyotaSequoialiability_onlyGeico$7700-
2026-03-19COFort Collins8052442unknownSeparated1997FordF-250liability_onlyGeico$78-1-
2026-08-31COColorado Springs8091729femaleMarried2013ChryslerTown and Countryliability_onlyGeico$7800-
2026-08-31COColorado Springs8091729femaleMarried2013ChryslerTown and Countryliability_onlyGeico$7800-
2026-07-10COPueblo8100430maleSingle2017NissanLeafliability_onlyGeico$7900-
2026-08-24COColorado Springs8090733femaleSingle2001FordF-150liability_onlyGeico$7900-
2026-08-26COColorado Springs8090966maleSingle2011CadillacCTSliability_onlyGeico$7900-
2026-08-29SCLiberty2965757femaleMarried2000ChevroletSilverado LDfull_coverageGeico$7900-
2026-09-04COAurora8001737femaleSingle2014DodgeAvengerliability_onlyGeico$7910Y
2026-08-24COColorado Springs8090733femaleSingle2001FordF-150liability_onlyGeico$7900-
2026-08-29SCLiberty2965757femaleMarried2000ChevroletSilverado LDfull_coverageGeico$8000-
2026-08-03COGrand Junction8150132maleSingle2007VolkswagenPassatliability_onlyGeico$8000-
2026-08-31COColorado Springs8090966maleSingle2011CadillacCTSliability_onlyGeico$8000-
2026-08-31TNDandridge3772530femaleMarried2019ChevroletBlazerfull_coverageGeico$8100-
2026-08-19COColorado Springs80911------liability_onlyGeico$8300-
2026-08-18TXGeorgetown7863329femaleSingle2026HondaCR-Vfull_coverageGeico$8400-
2026-08-29COWiggins8065428femaleSingle2016DodgeDurangoliability_onlyGeico$8401-
2026-08-29COWiggins8065428femaleSingle2016DodgeDurangoliability_onlyGeico$8501-
2026-08-07COPueblo8100738maleMarried2010FordMustangliability_onlyGeico$8500-
2026-09-03COColorado Springs8091647femaleSingle2016SubaruForesterliability_onlyGeico$8500-
2026-07-17SCDuncan2933452femaleSingle2005..liability_onlyGeico$8800-
2026-06-30AKWasilla99654-femaleSingle2008ToyotaScion xDliability_onlyGeico$8900-
2026-08-10COColorado Springs8091657maleSingle2022DodgeDurangoliability_onlyGeico$8900-
2026-07-10COPueblo8100430maleSingle2017NissanLeafliability_onlyGeico$8900-
2026-07-30COPeyton8083182femaleSingle2006BMWX5liability_onlyGeico$9100-
2026-09-05OKNorman7301938maleSingle2006CadillacCTSliability_onlyGeico$9100-
2026-08-17COFort Collins8052128femaleSingle2004ToyotaHighlanderliability_onlyGeico$9300-
2026-08-14COBoulder8030332maleMarried2007Chevychevyliability_onlyGeico$9300-
2026-08-05TXGeorgetown7863329femaleSingle2026HondaCR-Vfull_coverageGeico$9700-
2026-08-20OKRattan7456251maleSingle---liability_onlyGeico$9700-
2026-05-23COEnglewood8011029maleMarried2006Infinity-liability_onlyGeico$9900-
2026-03-19CODenver--unknownunknown2015FordF-250liability_onlyGeico$99-1-
2026-05-28----unknownunknown---liability_onlyGeico$99---
2026-08-05SCSpartanburg2930256femaleSingle2012ChevroletImpalaliability_onlyGeico$9900-
2026-09-03COColorado Springs8091028femaleSingle2008HondaAccordliability_onlyGeico$9900-
2026-08-04SCEnoree2933544maleSingle2005JeepGrand Cherokeeliability_onlyGeico$10000-
2026-08-26COFruita8152125femaleSingle2010ToyotaCorollaliability_onlyGeico$10102-
2026-09-09COBoulder8030538maleSeparated2020ChevroletBlazerfull_coverageGeico$10300-
2026-08-27COColorado Springs8093846maleSingle---liability_onlyGeico$10600-
2026-07-28SCSpartanburg2930138femaleDivorced2013FordFocusliability_onlyGeico$10900-
2026-08-22SCDuncan2933459femaleWidowed2021ChevroletBlazerfull_coverageGeico$11000-
2026-07-02SCFountain Inn2964433femaleSingle2026ToyotaCamryfull_coverageGeico$11000-
2026-08-28COColorado Springs8092136femaleSingle2007FordMustangliability_onlyGeico$11000-
2026-08-28COColorado Springs8092136femaleSingle2007FordMustangliability_onlyGeico$11000-
2026-08-21CODenver8023128femaleSingle2013FordSonatafull_coverageGeico$11100-
2026-07-22OKMead7344945femaleSingle2012GMCAcadialiability_onlyGeico$11200-
2026-08-28CODenver8022034maleSingle2023MazdaCX-30full_coverageGeico$11200-
2026-08-21COAurora8001450maleMarried2016AudiA4 allroadliability_onlyGeico$11200-
2026-08-28CODenver8020355femaleSingle2006LexusESfull_coverageGeico$11300-
2026-07-29COColorado Springs8090729maleSingle2015Chrysler200liability_onlyGeico$11500-
2026-07-29COColorado Springs8090729maleSingle2015Chrysler200liability_onlyGeico$11500-
2026-07-17SCGaffney2934147femaleSingle2009LexusRXfull_coverageGeico$11500-
2026-04-08COColorado Springs80916-unknownunknown2013RAM-liability_onlyGeico$1161--
2026-05-22AKWasilla9962318unknownunknown1999FordTaurusliability_onlyGeico$11700-
2026-09-02TNDandridge3772530femaleMarried2019ChevroletBlazerfull_coverageGeico$11700-
2026-03-24SCGreenville2961725maleSingle2018FordF-150liability_onlyGeico$118---
2026-06-29TXAustin7873433femaleSingle2013VolvoXC90liability_onlyGeico$11811Y
2026-08-17COPueblo8100422maleSingle2001FordExplorerliability_onlyGeico$11900-
2026-08-04AKChugiak9956719femaleSingle1999ChevroletSuburbanliability_onlyGeico$11900-
2026-08-19COPueblo8100430femaleSingle2017NissanVersafull_coverageGeico$12000Y
2026-08-25SCPickens2967132femaleMarried1999JeepCherokeefull_coverageGeico$12400-
2026-08-30COAurora8001724maleSingle2010ToyotaPriusfull_coverageGeico$12400-
2026-08-30COAurora8001724maleSingle2010ToyotaPriusliability_onlyGeico$12400-
2026-08-26SCPickens2967132femaleMarried1999JeepCherokeeliability_onlyGeico$12500-
2026-05-21SCGaffney2934146maleSingle2008FordMustang GTliability_onlyGeico$125---
2026-08-20COAurora8001450maleMarried2016AudiA4 allroadliability_onlyGeico$12500-
2026-09-03CODenver8021640femaleSingle2010InfinitiG37liability_onlyGeico$13000-
2026-09-08COGrand Junction8150430femaleSingle2019ToyotaTundrafull_coverageGeico$13100-
2026-09-08CODenver8021640femaleSingle2010InfinitiG37liability_onlyGeico$13100-
2026-09-08CODenver8021640femaleSingle2010InfinitiG37liability_onlyGeico$13100-
2026-08-10SCSimpsonville2968033femaleSingle2014HyundaiSonatafull_coverageGeico$13200-
2026-08-17SCSimpsonville2968033femaleSingle2014HyundaiSonatafull_coverageGeico$13600-
2026-09-05---------liability_onlyGeico$13600-
2026-06-17CONew castle8164727femaleSingle2020FordEscapefull_coverageGeico$13600-
2026-05-26SCSpartanburg2930627femaleSingle2013HyundaiSonatafull_coverageGeico$13700-
2026-09-01COColorado Springs8090931maleSingle2009SubaruOutbackliability_onlyGeico$13900-
2026-06-30CODenver8020232femaleSingle2024KiaSportagefull_coverageGeico$14000-
2026-08-11COColorado Springs8090557femaleDivorced2021Toyota4Runnerfull_coverageGeico$14000-
2026-08-10COPueblo8100538femaleMarried2003ToyotaHighlanderliability_onlyGeico$14400-
2026-03-19COColorado Springs8090539femaleSingle2007ChevyImpalaliability_onlyGeico$1441--
2026-08-21CODenver8021430maleSingle2008SubaruLegacyliability_onlyGeico$14400-
2026-08-26GADecatur3003249maleSingle2012ChevroletCruzeliability_onlyGeico$14500-
2026-08-04SCLiberty2965726maleSingle2020FordCordova Sedanfull_coverageGeico$14600-
2026-09-08CO-8001352femaleSingle2017HyundaiSonatafull_coverageGeico$14700-
2026-04-15SCSparkburg2930331maleSingle2015HyundaiAccentfull_coverageGeico$14811-
2026-07-09SCRuby2974137femaleSingle2022DodgeChargerliability_onlyGeico$14900-
2026-03-16OR---unknownunknown2022FordEscapefull_coverageGeico$150---
2026-08-03CODenver8020423maleSingle2012NissanVersaliability_onlyGeico$15020-
2026-04-03----unknownunknown2002-SuburbanunknownGeico$151---
2026-05-15SC---femaleunknown2012KiaOptimaliability_onlyGeico$151---
2026-05-29NC--35femaleSingle2017NissanRogueliability_onlyGeico$15500-
2026-04-03---27femaleMarried2021KiaFortefull_coverageGeico$15501-
2026-08-24COBayfield8112232maleSingle2017HyundaiSonatafull_coverageGeico$15600-
2026-07-31---23maleSingle2012Fordfocusliability_onlyGeico$15700-
2026-08-25COColorado Springs8090931maleSingle2009SubaruOutbackfull_coverageGeico$15800-
2026-06-17SCAbbeville2962029femaleSingle2016CadillacSRXfull_coverageGeico$15802Y
2026-08-17COColorado Springs8091532maleSingle2024HondaHR-Vfull_coverageGeico$15901-
2026-08-31COCOLORADO SPRINGS8092558maleSingle2017HondaCR-Vfull_coverageGeico$15900-
2026-04-17COColorado Springs80922-unknownSingle2019--full_coverageGeico$15902-
2026-04-03CODenver80221-unknownunknown2021Kia-full_coverageGeico$160---
2026-07-16SCSpartanburg2930154femaleSingle2016BMWX5full_coverageGeico$16000-
2026-06-29TXAustin7873433femaleSingle2013VolvoXC90liability_onlyGeico$16011Y
2026-06-24SCAnderson2962440femaleSingle2008KiaRioliability_onlyGeico$16200-
2026-08-31SCBluffton2991018femaleSingle2016HondaHR-Vliability_onlyGeico$16300-
2026-08-12GALavonia3055326maleSingle2022KiaK5full_coverageGeico$16400-
2026-06-24COBoulder80302-femaleSingle2017NissanRoguefull_coverageGeico$16700-
2026-08-05AZHereford85615------full_coverageGeico$16700-
2026-08-24SCLiberty2965767maleSingle2018FordFusionfull_coverageGeico$16900-
2026-06-24COColorado Springs8091323--2026MazdaCX-50full_coverageGeico$17000-
2026-03-20CO---unknownunknown---full_coverageGeico$171---
2026-07-16CODenver8020656maleMarried2021SubaruForesterfull_coverageGeico$17100-
2026-07-14COColorado Springs8090447femaleSingle2023NissanRoguefull_coverageGeico$17100-
2026-05-30CO---unknownunknown2017NissanRoguefull_coverageGeico$173-1-
2026-07-03COColorado Springs8090447femaleSingle2023NissanRoguefull_coverageGeico$17400-
2026-05-05----unknownSingle2024NissanAltimafull_coverageGeico$17500-
2026-09-04COAurora80012------full_coverageGeico$17500-
2026-05-25SCBerylton2962758maleDivorced2018RAM-full_coverageGeico$17600-
2026-04-15AKWasilla9965448maleSingle2020ChevroletEquinoxfull_coverageGeico$17601Y
2026-03-21SCGaffney2934020femaleSingle2021NissanTitanfull_coverageGeico$17700-
2026-08-24TXFort Worth7611058maleSingle2008FordF-150full_coverageGeico$17700-
2026-05-22GADelta8141632femaleSingle2022NissanAltimafull_coverageGeico$178---
2026-07-10FLNew Port Richey3465233maleSingle2014HondaCivicfull_coverageGeico$17911-
2026-07-10FLNew Port Richey3465233maleSingle2014HondaCivicfull_coverageGeico$17911-
2026-07-10FLNew Port Richey3465233maleSingle2014HondaCivicfull_coverageGeico$17911-
2026-07-28SCEasley2964053maleSingle2003JeepGrand Cherokeeliability_onlyGeico$17900-
2026-09-08SCGaffney2934126femaleSingle2017NissanAltimafull_coverageGeico$18100-
2026-03-26----unknownunknown---full_coverageGeico$182---
2026-03-25SCParkville2955031maleSingle2008ToyotaTundraliability_onlyGeico$18310-
2026-08-27COColorado Springs8092618maleSingle2001SubaruForesterliability_onlyGeico$18400-
2026-09-03COBoulder8030342femaleSingle2018JeepWrangler JKfull_coverageGeico$18600-
2026-05-29COFort Collins8052620maleSingle2000ToyotaAvalonfull_coverageGeico$18610-
2026-09-03CODenver8021931femaleSingle2015JeepGrand Cherokeefull_coverageGeico$18801-
2026-08-18COColorado Springs8092242femaleSingle2017KiaSorentofull_coverageGeico$18800-
2026-09-04AKWasilla99654------full_coverageGeico$18900-
2026-08-03SCYork2974525femaleSingle2013NissanAltimaliability_onlyGeico$19000-
2026-05-21COGrand Junction8150424femaleMarried2017ChevyCruzefull_coverageGeico$19100-
2026-05-27-Leeds--unknownunknown2017ChevyCruzefull_coverageGeico$191---
2026-03-16ORMill City97360-unknownMarried2022FordEscapefull_coverageGeico$19300-
2026-08-12COAspen8161165maleMarried2026HyundaiPalisadefull_coverageGeico$19300-
2026-03-30COThornton--maleSingle2021BuickEnvisionfull_coverageGeico$1941--
2026-03-31----unknownunknown-Buick-full_coverageGeico$195---
2026-07-07COColorado Springs8090432maleSingle2025FordMaverickfull_coverageGeico$19700-
2026-03-18----unknownunknown2013Chevrolet-full_coverageGeico$202---
2026-03-18----unknownunknown2013Chevrolet-full_coverageGeico$202---
2026-08-12SCEasley2964031femaleSingle2025HyundaiKonafull_coverageGeico$20200-
2026-03-19SCSpartanburg29301-unknownunknown---unknownGeico$202---
2026-05-21CODenver8024716femaleSingle2014KiaOptimaliability_onlyGeico$20510-
2026-09-07CODenver8024932femaleSingle2017ChevroletTraversefull_coverageGeico$20500-
2026-09-08SCGreenville2960525maleSingle2023ToyotaRAV4full_coverageGeico$20500-
2026-06-24COColorado Springs8090324maleSingle2025ToyotaCamryfull_coverageGeico$20700-
2026-09-01COColorado Springs8091027maleMarried2022ChevroletSilverado HDfull_coverageGeico$20700-
2026-09-05CODenver8023925femaleSingle2018Chrysler300full_coverageGeico$20800-
2026-07-03COGrand Junction8150169maleWidowed2024ChevroletMalibufull_coverageGeico$20900-
2026-08-29SCSpartanburg2930619maleSingle2014JeepCherokeeliability_onlyGeico$21000-
2026-08-29SCSpartanburg2930619maleSingle2014JeepCherokeeliability_onlyGeico$21000-
2026-09-01COCOLORADO SPRINGS8092558maleSingle2017HondaCR-Vfull_coverageGeico$21000-
2026-08-01COFountain8081721maleSingle2026KawasakiZX636full_coverageGeico$21100-
2026-07-28FLMilton3257026maleSingle2023MazdaCX-5full_coverageGeico$21200-
2026-08-21SCBelton2962730femaleSingle2025NissanKicks MPVfull_coverageGeico$21400-
2026-09-02CODenver8022147femaleSingle2012FordFocusfull_coverageGeico$21400-
2026-07-30SCFairfax2982749maleSingle2017CadillacEscaladefull_coverageGeico$21500-
2026-08-14CODenver8021931femaleSingle2015JeepGrand Cherokeefull_coverageGeico$22501-
2026-07-10COColorado Springs8090719maleSingle2009KiaSorentoliability_onlyGeico$22800-
2026-04-09COWellington8054942femaleSingle2025ChevySilverado 1500full_coverageGeico$2302--
2026-04-20COColorado Springs8090631femaleSingle2026HyundaiElantrafull_coverageGeico$23100-
2026-08-07COFountain80817-maleMarried---full_coverageGeico$23300-
2026-04-18COColorado Springs80906-femaleSingle2018KiaSportagefull_coverageGeico$23400-
2026-04-18----unknownunknown---full_coverageGeico$234---
2026-05-15COEvergreen8043945maleSingle2025NissanAltimaliability_onlyGeico$235---
2026-08-14COColorado Springs8091629maleSingle2018KiaFortefull_coverageGeico$23800-
2026-08-26COBrighton8060232femaleSingle2013VolkswagenPassatfull_coverageGeico$23800-
2026-08-26COBrighton8060232femaleSingle2013VolkswagenPassatfull_coverageGeico$23800-
2026-06-26COColorado Springs80906------full_coverageGeico$23900-
2026-06-29COColorado Springs8092832maleMarried2015ChevroletEquinoxfull_coverageGeico$24000-
2026-06-29COColorado Springs8092832maleMarried2015ChevroletEquinoxfull_coverageGeico$24000-
2026-06-29COColorado Springs8092832maleMarried2015ChevroletEquinoxfull_coverageGeico$24000-
2026-08-29COCOLORADO CITY8101953femaleMarried2014FordExplorerfull_coverageGeico$24100-
2026-08-19COColorado Springs8091141maleMarried2012HondaOdysseyfull_coverageGeico$24500-
2026-08-27COColorado Springs8091124femaleSingle2025Mazda3full_coverageGeico$24600-
2026-06-24COColorado Springs8091041maleMarried2021AcuraRDXfull_coverageGeico$24700-
2026-09-02COPueblo8100126maleSingle2019RAM1500full_coverageGeico$24900-
2026-07-28COColorado Springs8090346femaleSingle2019ChevroletEquinoxfull_coverageGeico$25000-
2026-05-12COColorado Springs8091142maleMarried2019ToyotaCamryfull_coverageGeico$25330-
2026-08-31COLittleton8012024femaleSingle2020FordEcosportfull_coverageGeico$25300-
2026-08-18CODenver8023731maleSingle2024BMWi4full_coverageGeico$25400-
2026-08-21SCSpartanburg2930142femaleSingle2013HyundaiSonatafull_coverageGeico$25600-
2026-07-31CODenver80204------full_coverageGeico$25700-
2026-06-24COColorado Springs8091323maleSingle2023KiaRiofull_coverageGeico$25800-
2026-07-01COFort Collins8052643femaleMarried2023FordEscapefull_coverageGeico$25900-
2026-04-09COPalisade8152650femaleDivorced2026ToyotaTundra Limitedfull_coverageGeico$26101-
2026-07-28SCSpartanburg2930619maleSingle2014JeepCherokeeliability_onlyGeico$26300-
2026-09-03COCOLORADO CITY8101953femaleMarried2014FordExplorerfull_coverageGeico$26300-
2026-08-11OREugene9740240maleSingle2013BMW328ifull_coverageGeico$26500-
2026-08-14SCInman2934923maleSingle2022HyundaiTucsonfull_coverageGeico$26700-
2026-06-17SCHeath Springs2905830femaleSingle2014Chrysler300full_coverageGeico$26800-
2026-05-20COColorado Springs8090440unknownSingle2013HondaRidgelinefull_coverageGeico$272---
2026-08-03TXHouston7706736femaleSingle2018Chrysler300full_coverageGeico$27300-
2026-09-01CODenver8023341maleSingle2024HyundaiSonatafull_coverageGeico$27300-
2026-08-29CODenver8020433femaleSingle2019ChevroletTraversefull_coverageGeico$27503-
2026-08-24COCommerce City80022------full_coverageGeico$27600-
2026-08-28COClifton81520------full_coverageGeico$27700-
2026-07-17SCSpartanburg2931618maleSingle2019FordF-250liability_onlyGeico$27800-
2026-06-24VAWinchester22601------full_coverageGeico$27800-
2026-07-03COColorado Springs8091836maleSingle2018SubaruWRXfull_coverageGeico$27900-
2026-06-24SCRock Hill2973022maleSingle2011FordFusionfull_coverageGeico$27900-
2026-08-17ORSalem9730334femaleSingle2016KiaOptimafull_coverageGeico$27900-
2026-09-01COColorado Springs80913------full_coverageGeico$27900-
2026-06-30SCAnderson2962562maleMarried2015HyundaiGenesisfull_coverageGeico$28000-
2026-06-26TXLake Dallas7506559femaleDivorced2012NissanTitanfull_coverageGeico$28200-
2026-04-06COAurora8001273maleMarried2020Toyota4Runnerfull_coverageGeico$284-2-
2026-06-24TXLake Dallas7506559femaleDivorced2012NissanTitanfull_coverageGeico$28400-
2026-07-15SCAnderson2962562maleMarried2015HyundaiGenesisfull_coverageGeico$28600-
2026-03-31----unknownunknown2021KiaTelluridefull_coverageGeico$287---
2026-04-02SD---unknownunknown2020MitsubishiOutlanderfull_coverageGeico$289--Y
2026-08-31COColorado Springs8092120maleSingle2026ToyotaCamryfull_coverageGeico$29000-
2026-08-31COLittleton8012024femaleSingle2020FordEcosportfull_coverageGeico$29100-
2026-08-17SCChesnee2932332femaleSingle2025ToyotaCorollafull_coverageGeico$29200-
2026-06-24COLimon8082821femaleSingle2023HondaAccordfull_coverageGeico$29200-
2026-07-20SCSpartanburg2930341femaleSingle2014DodgeChargerfull_coverageGeico$29500-
2026-06-24SCSpartanburg2930134femaleSingle2007BMW328xifull_coverageGeico$29800-
2026-09-02CODenver8022938maleSingle2018RAM1500full_coverageGeico$30000Y
2026-09-01COColorado Springs8091122maleSingle2021RAM1500full_coverageGeico$30400-
2026-07-21GASnellville3007860maleSingle2017NissanFrontierliability_onlyGeico$30500-
2026-09-08CODenver8022325maleSingle2025JeepGladiatorfull_coverageGeico$30500-
2026-08-15COColorado Springs8091731femaleMarried2016ChevroletImpala Limitedfull_coverageGeico$30600-
2026-08-05COColorado Springs8091141maleMarried2012HondaOdysseyfull_coverageGeico$30900-
2026-08-28COFountain8081750maleSingle2015FordExplorerfull_coverageGeico$30900-
2026-05-14SCCampobello29322-unknownunknown---unknownGeico$311---
2026-09-08CODenver8022325maleSingle2025JeepGladiatorfull_coverageGeico$31400-
2026-08-10CO-8030124maleSingle2015GMCAcadiafull_coverageGeico$31600-
2026-08-15SCCalhoun Falls2962828femaleSingle2007FordEdgefull_coverageGeico$31600-
2026-08-15SCCalhoun Falls2962828femaleSingle2007FordEdgefull_coverageGeico$31600-
2026-07-20COColorado Springs8091122maleSingle2014JeepGrand Cherokeefull_coverageGeico$31700-
2026-09-07COEdwards8163220maleSingle2016ChevroletSilveradofull_coverageGeico$31800Y
2026-08-29COPueblo8100536femaleMarried2017ChevroletSilveradofull_coverageGeico$32111-
2026-08-15SCGreer2965131femaleSingle2012HondaPilotliability_onlyGeico$32200-
2026-09-05COPueblo8100126maleSingle2019RAM1500full_coverageGeico$32600-
2026-06-27---------full_coverageGeico$32700-
2026-08-28SCGaffney2934139maleMarried2015GMCYukonfull_coverageGeico$32911-
2026-09-03CODenver8022332maleSingle2018ChevroletSilveradofull_coverageGeico$33000-
2026-03-26COColorado Springs80925-unknownMarried2023DodgeDurango RTfull_coverageGeico$33300-
2026-04-14COEvans80620-unknownunknown---unknownGeico$341---
2026-07-03CODenver8022236maleSingle2013GMCYukonfull_coverageGeico$34300Y
2026-08-13TXHouston7709138maleSingle2015InfinitiQ70full_coverageGeico$34400-
2026-07-27COColorado Springs8091320maleSingle2016VolkswagenJettafull_coverageGeico$34722-
2026-09-02COColorado Springs8091122maleSingle2021RAM1500full_coverageGeico$34800-
2026-07-23COEnglewood8011324maleSingle2015ToyotaCamryfull_coverageGeico$35000-
2026-05-20COColorado Springs8091533maleSingle2025RAM1500 Rebelfull_coverageGeico$35600-
2026-08-17ORSalem9730334femaleSingle2016KiaOptimafull_coverageGeico$35800-
2026-08-10---24femaleSingle2025Mazda3full_coverageGeico$36100-
2026-08-31COColorado Springs8092528maleMarried2018SubaruWRXfull_coverageGeico$36100-
2026-08-13CODenver8023829maleSingle2026ChevroletCorvettefull_coverageGeico$36300-
2026-05-27COPueblo8100828femaleSingle2023HondaHRZLXAWDfull_coverageGeico$368-0-
2026-09-05SCYork2974519femaleSingle2009HondaAccordfull_coverageGeico$37300-
2026-08-20COFountain8081750maleSingle2015FordExplorerfull_coverageGeico$37900-
2026-08-31COColorado Springs8091627maleSingle2023DodgeDurangofull_coverageGeico$38400-
2026-07-03CODenver8022826maleMarried2018InfinitiQ50full_coverageGeico$38910-
2026-07-28---41maleMarried2018ChevySilveradofull_coverageGeico$39100-
2026-07-31COCastle Rock8010441maleMarried2018ChevySilveradofull_coverageGeico$39100-
2026-04-16ORHubbard97032-unknownunknown2010DodgeRamfull_coverageGeico$400---
2026-07-15---------full_coverageGeico$40200-
2026-07-15---------full_coverageGeico$40200-
2026-05-26COBoulder8030321maleSingle2025JeepWrangler 4XEfull_coverageGeico$40400-
2026-05-26----unknownunknown---unknownGeico$407---
2026-04-15ORHubbard-21femaleSingle2019RAM-full_coverageGeico$410-1-
2026-08-14SCSpartanburg2930734maleSingle2012ToyotaRAV4full_coverageGeico$41900-
2026-07-23COPueblo8100458femaleMarried2009ToyotaCamryfull_coverageGeico$43600-
2026-08-27COColorado Springs8092430maleSingle2016Mercedes-BenzE-Classfull_coverageGeico$44000-
2026-08-15CODenver8021922maleSingle2024ChevroletSilveradofull_coverageGeico$44500-
2026-08-15CODenver8021922maleSingle2024ChevroletSilveradofull_coverageGeico$44600-
2026-08-21COColorado Springs8091138femaleMarried---full_coverageGeico$45500-
2026-07-16AKWasilla9965418maleSingle2019SubaruWRXfull_coverageGeico$46800-
2026-08-29COVictor8086021femaleSingle2016Toyota4Runnerfull_coverageGeico$46900-
2026-08-29COVictor8086021femaleSingle2016Toyota4Runnerfull_coverageGeico$46900-
2026-06-30COColorado Springs8092553femaleSingle2020Chevysolicfull_coverageGeico$48500-
2026-08-06COColorado Springs8091938maleMarried2022FordF-150full_coverageGeico$49500-
2026-08-06COColorado Springs8091938maleMarried2022FordF-150full_coverageGeico$49500-
2026-07-13SCSpartanburg2930658maleSingle2021CadillacCT5full_coverageGeico$50010-
2026-06-24COAurora80012------full_coverageGeico$51300-
2026-08-31SCRock Hill2973034maleSingle2018NissanPathfinderfull_coverageGeico$62700-
2026-09-02COColorado Springs8091639femaleDivorced2018NissanSentrafull_coverageGeico$65410-
2026-07-14---------full_coverageGeico$65500-
2026-08-05SCJonesville2935324maleSingle2015HyundaiVelosterfull_coverageGeico$80000-
2026-08-14AKWasilla9965421maleSingle2024AudiA4full_coverageGeico$85600-
2026-09-01CODenver8023341maleSingle2024HyundaiSonatafull_coverageGeico$163900-

Source: A Plus Insurance first-party quote data.

All quotes gathered by licensed agents at A Plus Insurance. Figures update automatically as our agents log new quotes. How we collect this data.

The pattern in our data: Geico usually wins for clean records, Progressive is more flexible on violations and SR-22s. A licensed agent can quote you both in one call: (888) 445-2793 or get a free quote online.

Progressive vs Geico

Compare Progressive vs Geico insurance options with A Plus Insurance to find the best coverage for you.

Get Quote Now ๐Ÿ“ž Call 888-445-2793
Badge Badge Badge

Overview of Progressive vs Geico

Progressive Key Features

Progressive offers flexible coverage with Snapshot telematics for 10-30% discounts. In 2023, 40% of policyholders saved $200/year. Ideal for high-risk drivers.

Geico Key Features

Geico provides competitive rates with 24/7 support and easy online quotes. Average savings of 15% on bundling, with 50 million policies in 2023.

A Plus Insurance Comparison

A Plus Insurance analyzes both for your needs, securing rates starting at $500/year. Get personalized advice to choose the best fit.

Progressive vs Geico FAQs

What is the main difference between Progressive and Geico?

Progressive emphasizes telematics for discounts, while Geico focuses on online convenience. In 2023, Progressive saved 40% of users $200/year via Snapshot. See Progressive vs Geico comparison.

Which has cheaper rates: Progressive or Geico?

Geico often has lower base rates, averaging $1,200/year, while Progressive excels for high-risk drivers. In 2023, 55% of shoppers chose Geico for savings. A Plus Insurance compares both.

Does Progressive offer better customer service?

Progressive scores 4.2/5 on J.D. Power, with 24/7 claims, slightly above Geico’s 4.1/5. In 2023, 30% of customers praised Progressive’s app. Check Progressive auto insurance.

Is Geico better for bundling?

Geico bundling saves 15-25%, or $300/year for 45% of policyholders in 2023. Progressive offers similar but with more home options. See Progressive vs Geico comparison.

Which is better for high-risk drivers?

Progressive specializes in high-risk, with SR22 filings for 20% of customers, saving $150/year. Geico is stricter. A Plus Insurance guides SR22 needs.

Does Progressive have more discounts?

Progressive offers 10-30% telematics discounts, used by 40% in 2023. Geico has 15% safe driver perks. See car insurance discounts.

Is Geico easier to use online?

Geico’s app has 4.5/5 ratings, with 50 million users in 2023. Progressive’s is 4.3/5. Both offer instant quotes.

Which covers rentals better?

Both extend liability to rentals, but Geico includes collision for 30 days. In 2023, 10% of users added rental coverage. See rental car insurance.

Does Progressive cover more states?

Progressive operates in all 50 states, like Geico. In 2023, both covered 99% of U.S. drivers. A Plus Insurance matches your state.

Which has better roadside assistance?

Geico’s roadside is $14/month, with 4.4/5 ratings. Progressive’s is $7/month. In 2023, 25% of users chose Geico for towing. See roadside assistance.

Is Progressive better for SR22?

Progressive handles SR22 for high-risk, with 30% of filings in 2023. Geico is limited. A Plus Insurance assists with SR22.

Which has faster claims?

Geico processes 80% of claims in 5 days, Progressive in 7. In 2023, both had 4/5 satisfaction. A Plus Insurance speeds claims.

Can I switch from Geico to Progressive?

Switching is easy, with no lapse if timed correctly. In 2023, 25% switched for savings. See how to cancel insurance.

Which is better for families?

Geico’s multi-car discounts save 15%, for 50% of families in 2023. Progressive offers teen driver perks. A Plus Insurance matches family needs.

Does Geico cover new drivers?

Geico offers teen discounts of 10-20%, saving $150/year for 30% of new drivers in 2023. Progressive has similar. See new driver insurance.

Which has better app ratings?

Geico’s app is 4.5/5, Progressive 4.3/5. In 2023, 45% used apps for quotes. Both are user-friendly.

Is Progressive better for bundling?

Progressive’s bundling saves 15-25%, or $300/year for 40% of customers in 2023. Geico is similar. See Progressive vs Geico comparison.

Which covers rentals better?

Geico includes collision for rentals up to 30 days, saving $20/day. Progressive offers similar. In 2023, 10% added rental coverage. See rental car insurance.

Does Geico have more coverage options?

Geico offers 12 add-ons like rideshare coverage, used by 20% in 2023. Progressive has 10. Both provide comprehensive choices.

Can I get quotes from both easily?

A Plus Insurance compares both in minutes, saving 15% on average. In 2023, 30% of shoppers used comparison tools. Start with us.

Which is better for seniors?

Geico offers 10% senior discounts, saving $100/year for 25% of seniors in 2023. Progressive has similar perks. A Plus Insurance matches needs.

Does Progressive have better online tools?

Progressive’s Snapshot app tracks driving for discounts, with 4.3/5 ratings. Geico’s is 4.5/5. Both are effective for 2023 users.

Which has faster claims processing?

Geico processes 80% of claims in 5 days, Progressive in 7. In 2023, both scored 4/5 satisfaction. A Plus Insurance accelerates claims.

Is Geico better for multi-car families?

Geico’s multi-car discounts save 15%, or $200/year for 50% of families in 2023. Progressive offers 12%. A Plus Insurance optimizes family plans.

Which is better for new drivers?

Progressive offers teen discounts of 10-20%, saving $150/year for 30% of new drivers in 2023. Geico has similar. See new driver insurance.

Does Progressive cover more vehicles?

Progressive insures up to 10 vehicles per policy, like Geico. In 2023, both covered 99% of U.S. vehicles. A Plus Insurance handles multi-vehicle quotes.

Which has better mobile app?

Geico’s app is 4.5/5, Progressive 4.3/5. In 2023, 45% used apps for claims. Both are highly rated.

Can I get SR22 from either?

Progressive specializes in SR22 for high-risk drivers, with 30% of filings in 2023. Geico is limited. A Plus Insurance assists with SR22 needs.

Which is better for homeowners?

Geico’s home bundling saves 15%, or $300/year in 2023. Progressive offers similar with more options. See home insurance companies.

Does Geico have more local agents?

Geico has 20,000 agents nationwide, Progressive 30,000. In 2023, both served 95% of U.S. locations. A Plus Insurance connects to local agents.

Progressive vs Geico Comparison

Compare key features of Progressive and Geico insurance.

FeatureProgressiveGeico
Average Annual Rate$1,300$1,200
Customer Satisfaction4.2/54.1/5
Bundling Savings15-25%15-25%
SR22 AvailabilityHighLimited
Service Area: Progressive vs Geico Nationwide
Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California Colorado Florida Georgia Idaho Indiana Iowa Kansas Louisiana Maine Maryland Michigan Mississippi Missouri Montana Nebraska

Progressive vs Geico

Progressive vs Geico offers distinct advantages for drivers, with Progressive excelling in telematics discounts (10-30% savings for 40% of users in 2023) and high-risk coverage like SR22s, while Geico leads in online convenience and base rates ($1,200/year average). Both provide liability, collision, and comprehensive options, with bundling saving 15-25%, or $300/year for 45% of policyholders. A Plus Insurance compares both, noting Progressive’s Snapshot app (4.3/5 rating) vs Geico’s user-friendly platform (4.5/5), helping choose based on needs. In 2023, Geico processed 80% of claims in 5 days, Progressive in 7. See Progressive vs Geico comparison for details.

Progressive suits families with multi-car discounts (12%) and new drivers (10-20% savings), while Geico shines for seniors (10% off) and rentals (30-day collision). Both cover 50 states, with Geico’s 50 million policies vs Progressive’s 27 million in 2023. A Plus Insurance tailors quotes, ensuring compliance with state minimums like Texas’s 30/60/25. Switching providers saved 25% of drivers $200/year in 2023. For high-risk, Progressive handles 30% of SR22s, Geico limited. Contact A Plus for personalized comparisons nationwide. Learn more at auto insurance comparison.

Scroll to Top